(Download) "Brower Co. V. Garrison" by Division One, Panel 1 Court of Appeals of Washington # eBook PDF Kindle ePub Free
eBook details
- Title: Brower Co. V. Garrison
- Author : Division One, Panel 1 Court of Appeals of Washington
- Release Date : January 20, 1970
- Genre: Law,Books,Professional & Technical,
- Pages : * pages
- Size : 62 KB
Description
SWANSON, J. - Henry W. Batts and wife, doing business as Batts Construction Co. (Batts), as general contractor, agreed to construct a truck sales and service building for Kenworth Northwest Sales & Service, Inc. (Kenworth). After construction of the facility was completed, The Brower Co., a subcontractor, brought a lien foreclosure action against Kenworth, the owner of the property, Batts, the general contractor, and other subcontractors, including United Plumbing & Heating, Inc. (United). United cross claimed to foreclose its lien claim for an alleged balance due on its subcontract. Kenworth then brought a separate action against Batts and its surety. It sought damages in excess of $425,000 claiming poor construction, real estate depreciation, and delayed performance damages. Batts counterclaimed seeking foreclosure of its lien claim of $81,209.01. These actions were consolidated for trial. The subcontractors' lien claims were settled during the course of the trial, and none are appealed from. United is the only subcontractor involved in an issue on this appeal. Batts received a judgment against Kenworth for $81,209.01, less a setoff to Kenworth for damages for deficiencies in the construction of the building and for loss of profits caused by Batts' failure to substantially complete the building within a reasonable time. The setoff totaled $79,811.50, thus netting Batts only $1,397.51. Batts has not appealed from that part of the judgment relating to deficiencies in construction but appeals from certain of the amounts allowed Kenworth as a setoff and the insufficiency of a setoff awarded Batts against United.